Fiscal surplus plunge exposes weaknesses in revenue strategy: BMP
Anjum Nisar calls for broadening tax base, curbing debt burden and reviving industrial growth

islamabad
The Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry’s Businessmen Panel (BMP) has expressed serious concern over a 40 per cent decline in Pakistan’s fiscal surplus during the first quarter of the current fiscal year, warning that falling revenues, mounting debt-servicing costs and shrinking provincial surpluses reflect deep-rooted weaknesses in the country’s fiscal management.
BMP Chairman and former FPCCI president Mian Anjum Nisar said the latest fiscal operations figures exposed the limitations of the government’s revenue-generation strategy, as the overall fiscal surplus dropped to Rs1.273 trillion in July-September 2026 from Rs2.12 trillion in the corresponding period last year.
He said the deterioration was particularly alarming because it came despite expenditure controls and cuts in subsidies, indicating that the country’s fiscal position remained vulnerable to weak revenue mobilisation and an increasingly expensive debt burden.
The decline in the surplus also highlighted the need to revisit existing economic policies rather than relying on short-term expenditure adjustments.
Anjum Nisar observed that total government revenue fell to Rs6.004 trillion from Rs6.2 trillion, while the revenue-to-GDP ratio declined from 4.9 per cent to 4.2 per cent.
He said such a decline raised serious questions about the effectiveness of the existing fiscal framework, particularly when the government continued to depend heavily on established taxpayers and the formal business sector to achieve its revenue targets.
He pointed out that although tax collections increased to Rs3.387 trillion from Rs3.153 trillion, the overall revenue position deteriorated because of a substantial decline in non-tax receipts. State Bank of Pakistan profits, a major component of non-tax revenue, dropped to Rs1.933 trillion from Rs2.43 trillion, contributing significantly to the overall shortfall.
The BMP chairman said the government needed to distinguish between genuine improvements in revenue generation and temporary increases in collections resulting from additional taxation.
Sustainable revenue growth could only be achieved through expansion of economic activity, higher industrial production, increased exports and the formalisation of untaxed sectors.
He stressed that repeatedly imposing additional taxes on existing taxpayers was neither an equitable nor a sustainable approach.
Excessive taxation, complicated procedures and frequent changes in fiscal policies were discouraging investment, restricting business expansion and weakening the competitiveness of domestic industries. Instead, the government should identify sectors and businesses operating outside the tax net and bring them into the documented economy through a transparent and facilitative taxation system.
Anjum Nisar also expressed concern over the 23 per cent increase in interest payments, which rose to Rs1.7 trillion during the first quarter against Rs1.378 trillion in the same period last year. He said the growing cost of debt servicing was absorbing an increasingly large portion of public resources, leaving limited fiscal space for development projects, infrastructure, education, healthcare and industrial support.
He said the rising interest burden was particularly troubling at a time when businesses were struggling with high borrowing costs, expensive electricity and gas, and increased production expenses. The government needed to reduce its dependence on borrowing by improving fiscal discipline, expanding the productive base of the economy and creating an environment conducive to private-sector investment.
The BMP chairman further observed that the primary surplus had also declined to Rs2.97 trillion, or 2.1 per cent of GDP, from Rs3.5 trillion, or 2.8 per cent, a year earlier. This indicated that even after excluding interest payments, the government’s fiscal position had weakened, making structural reforms increasingly important.
He said expenditure management should focus on eliminating waste, improving the performance of public-sector entities and rationalising non-development spending instead of restricting essential development allocations. Although subsidies declined to Rs84.6 billion from Rs120 billion, the government must ensure that fiscal adjustments did not disproportionately affect low-income households, agriculture and productive industries.
Anjum Nisar also drew attention to the 23 per cent decline in provincial cash surpluses to Rs600 billion from Rs781 billion. Punjab’s surplus fell to Rs333 billion from Rs442 billion, while Sindh’s declined to Rs181 billion from Rs209 billion. Although Khyber Pakhtunkhwa improved its surplus to Rs102 billion, Balochistan recorded a deficit of Rs16 billion against a surplus of Rs53 billion in the corresponding period last year.
He said the weakening provincial fiscal position demonstrated the importance of stronger coordination between the federal and provincial governments, particularly in revenue mobilisation, expenditure planning and financial management. Provinces needed to improve their own-source revenues and ensure that available resources were spent efficiently on development and public services.
The BMP chairman maintained that Pakistan could not achieve lasting fiscal stability through taxation and spending cuts alone. A sustainable economic recovery required consistent policies, lower production costs, improved access to financing, export diversification and greater confidence among domestic and foreign investors.



